France fishing row about 'poll pressure' says expert
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. More info
Steven Barratt, a barrister and writer for The Spectator believes France is now “as bad as Poland” by acting alone to issue sanctions to the UK following the escalation of the fishing row. French president Mr Macron, who is currently in the presence of Boris Johnson at Cop26 in Glasgow, issued the UK with a deadline of Tuesday for movement in the row over French access to British fishing waters.
Paris threatened to disrupt the flow of UK exports from Tuesday unless a deal was reached. Disruptions could include increased checks on British fishing boats and trucks – and tariffs on electricity to the Channel Islands.
Macron has also called for EU-UK cooperation in other areas to be frozen until the dispute is solved.
Mr Barratt tweeted: “The Rule of Law Crisis is an existential threat to the EU
“People obsessed with the politics (and hating the UK) are missing this. If France can act alone now, any of the other 26 can and in any treaty
“Without the Rule of Law the EU does not exist
“France = as bad as Poland.”
Mr Barratt’s tweet references an ongoing conflict between the EU and Poland after the Polish government issued a series of judicial reforms which have the potential to challenge the EU’s legal foundation.
Poland made changes relating to the appointment, discipline and removal of Polish judges, which the EU fears could cause the bloc’s common legal system to unravel, as it effectively decouples Poland’s legal system from other member states.
LIVE UPDATES: Brexit LIVE: Frost hands EU three-step blueprint for fixing deal
In an escalation of the dispute, a polish court ruling in October set the primacy of Polish law above EU law, effectively rejecting the legal bedrock upon which the European Union is based.
In a separate tweet, the lawyer added: “What mattered about the German case was not EU bonds. It was the court setting a precedent that Poland walked through
“What matters here is not fish, it’s France doing the same
“There is no EU if all its powers are stolen by Member States.”
Tory Brexiteer savages Insulate Britain as they wreak havoc on roads [REACTION]
Stark warning: COP26 will end in failure [INSIGHT]
What will happen if France doesn’t back down on fishing threats? [ANALYSIS]
The Polish ruling followed a precedent set by Germany, who also confronted the EU’s legal order when judges found that the European Central Bank (ECB) had overstepped its mandate by approving bond-buying programs.
The German courts also dismissed a ruling by the European Court of Justice.
Franklin Dehousse, a law professor and former judge at the European Court of Justice, told Politico that “Germany set a dangerous precedent by attacking the primacy of EU law.”
Ms Truss told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that, despite French threats, UK fishing licences had been awarded to French boats “entirely in accordance” with the post-Brexit deal between the EU and UK.
She has also threatened legal action unless France withdraws the threats, saying that the UK is prepared to “use the dispute resolution mechanism in the trade deal we signed with the EU to take action against the French”.
“We’re simply not going to roll over in the face of these threats,” she added.
She added that France was acting “unfairly” in setting a deadline for issuing more fishing permits.
In an attempt to solve the dispute between France and the UK, representatives from the European Commission, France, the UK and the Channel Islands are holding talks via video link today.
A commission spokesperson said they hoped the meeting would bring a “swift solution on the outstanding issues”.
Source: Read Full Article